Copyright laws are incredibly important to abide
by. People and companies constantly infringe on other people's work and their actions usually end up in a lawsuit. Back in June the famous duo,
The Black Keys, filed two lawsuits against Pizza Hut and Home Depot claiming that these companies used songs in their commercials that were very similar to their popular tunes. Home Depot used a tune in their commercial that was very similar to The Black Keys' song "
Lonely Boy" and Pizza Hut used a tune that sounded similar to the song "
Gold On The Ceiling". Naturally both companies denied that the tunes used in their commercials sounded similar to those of The Black Keys.
I wasn't able to track down the Home Depot commercial but you can watch the Pizza Hut commercial
here.
Just now have the
lawsuits been settled between the band and the companies. The Black Keys won the lawsuit but the exact details of the settlement were not released.
This lawsuit created some controversy over whether or not the tunes really did sound similar to the original Black Keys songs. Some believe the tunes are not similar enough to create a lawsuit while others believe they are almost identical.
Whether or not the tunes are similar, some people were outraged over the fact that The Black Keys decided to even file a lawsuit. They see them as being ridiculous, cheap and greedy. Artists and celebrities already make millions, so why are they creating petty lawsuits for more money?
I don't think this is an issue about money. Artists want to protect their work. They created their songs and they want to make sure that no one else is making a profit off of their work. This is a very valid reason to sue companies over copyright infringements. If there was no penalty for stealing other people's work then no one would truly get credit for what they created. These artists work very hard to be in the position that they are in and they should be recognized for their hard work.
Even when artists allow companies to use their songs in commercials they are often seen as selling out. So really, they can't win.
Currently there is no news as to whether or not The Black Keys will be donating any of their proceeds. I think artists have the right to protect their work, but when it comes to the money they receive I think that they should donate it. They issue these lawsuits so that other people can't steal there work and by donating their settlement money they are proving that point. It shouldn't be about the money but instead it should be about protecting their intellectual property.
Country star LeAnn Rimes is currently admits a lawsuit. She claims that any
money she receives from the lawsuit will go directly to the Trevor Project, which aids homosexual teens that are struggling with their sexuality. This is the best approach that a celebrity can take when launching a lawsuit.
It is important that intellectual property is protected, but the biggest issue with celebrity lawsuits is that they can come off as being greedy. Artists have a right to protect their intellectual property but to avoid being greedy they should donate their proceeds to a worthy charity.
What do you think about celebrity lawsuits? Do you think that donating their settlement money to a charity is good enough? Or do you think they shouldn't be issuing lawsuits at all?